The People News, a free newspaper serving Cleveland Tennessee (TN) and Bradley County Tennessee (Tn).





Of Bradley County Tn.


AUGUST  2007

                            The People News, a free newspaper serving Cleveland and Bradley County Tn.

HOME

BACK ISSUE ARCHIVE

EDITORIALS

LETTERS

CONTACT US

Personal Responsibility

By Joe Kirkpatrick

Today, we live in a society of people who always blame someone else for their problems or actions. A society whose court system actually let someone use the "twinkie" defense: In a famous case, an attorney was allowed to use a defense that his client ate too many twinkies, thusly giving him a sugar imbalance that effected his thinking, and for that reason, his client should not be held responsible for the murder he had committed.

We had a case before the beer board several years ago that is a very good example of what I am talking about. The management at O'Charley's had expelled someone under age from the bar area, who then exited the building, and threw a brick through the window. The manager immediately called the police, but by the time they arrived, a crowd had spilled out into the parking lot. I have always had the view if you give a license to serve alcohol, then get a bunch of people in there drinking, you are occasionally going to have problems - that just goes with the territory. From the beer boards point of view, we have to consider how the management of the establishment handles the problem. In O'Charley's case, the manager recognized the problem, expelled the problem maker, and quickly called the police. O'Charley's was brought before the board, and a very lengthy hearing was held. The previous board chairman allowed all kind testimony in the meeting, most of which was totally unsubstantiated, or irrelevant, or both.

Joe Kirkpatrick


One lady was allowed to testify that one night during the past year, she had dropped her son off at O'Charley's after 10 PM when she was on her way to work. Her son met a friend there, the friend had too much to drink, her son asked the friend for a ride home, and got into the car with him. As far as I know, her son did not put on a seat belt, and was killed within a mile of O'Charley's when the car wrecked, and he was thrown out. In testimony before the beer board, the mother stated, "O'Charley's killed my son."

Now, as much as I feel for anyone who loses their child, this lady's child was an adult. If I drop my adult child off at O'Charley's after 10pm at night, my expectation is they are not going in there for a steak dinner. This lady's adult child, went in, sat with his friend who he saw drink too much, made the decision to get in the car with him, and furthermore, chose not to put on his seat belt. O'Charley's did not kill this lady's child - A drunk driver killed this lady's child. A server in a crowded bar cannot be expected to measure each patrons sobriety level. That is an unreasonable expectation. It's the same with people who sue gun manufacturers - the gun doesn't kill someone - another person kills someone. If a person is murdered by someone who strangles them with a rope, do you ever see a lawsuit against the rope manufacturer?

It's time for people in our society to quit blaming all of their problems on someone else, and take personal responsibility for the decisions they make.
To my readers: Be sure and read next months column, "Identity Theft, Law Enforcement Style" - It could easily happen to you!
.

HOME

BACK ISSUE ARCHIVE

EDITORIALS

LETTERS

CONTACT US